I Was Here by Gayle Forman Review

I made this review for my Goodreads account, but I think the sight of composing view of my blog is making me to add some more about it. So, here it is, my amateur review of I Was Here book from Gayle Forman. As usual, a honest review from the sassy side of me.

The cover speaks about the inside of this book. It's not pretty, in my opinion.

I never leave a book, whether it is good or bad. Yeah, I mean the worst one. And I send this book a deep condolence of being considered as the latter one. And I have a LOT of reasons for that. So, I just needed to finish this book, as soon as I reached the chapter 3. I already had a gut feeling that this story would end terribly and just inevitably disappointing. 

Did you know what? I think some stories about suicide on Wattpad are even worth reading than this one. You know why, it is because the relationship between Cody and Meg. Meg is a keeper, we all know that and it is just easy to see from the description made by Cody. Then what is the use of Cody there? Cody is helpless and useless. Just because she struggles a lot than Meg, doesn't mean a friend like her cannot see Meg's depression! It is just ridiculous. The story from the beginning only shows how terrible Cody was. How come a best friend (as Forman mentions it all over the place) not knowing the struggle of the other? Real friendship would know that!!! Except Cody is not halfheartedly befriended Meg and that is another case, which I had hope I would find that by the end of this book. But, no, I cannot find it!! Cody is too ignorant and insensitive. She is self-centered too. And she always used Tricia and her father as the reasons of EVERY single thing that she thinks burdening her. And as much as I hate to say this, but Cody is only using Meg's happiness including her parents as an escape from her miserable life. Hello, it is not only you who is suffering, so please get out of le spotlight, please!

Second reason is Ben the a**hole. I hate it when this book only offers you less plot twists. And the chosen one is offering this guy who sleeps with his groupies. As soon as I reached the line where  he expresses his assholeness about how often he sleeps with his 'friends', I was like what the fuck?! I never thought the future of this book would involve his presence anymore. I always thought he is like additional character to this book. Hell no- he has the character of a perfect match for the protagonist/main character from a romance story book. As soon as I reached chapter 6 or 7, it was like BOOOM! Someone throws a grenade to my brain, and let it think otherwise. Cody shows her interest towards Ben!!!!!! what the f*ck!!!! and this is exactly the phase when I strongly recommend you not to read this book! Things were getting even worst when Cody sleeps with him. I feel like wanting to vomit on her face. Cody is the main character. She is the major one in this book but why did Forman give her bad personal traits? Like hello, Meg is your fucking friend, so why did you sleep with a guy who becomes the reason she commits suicide??! Are you a moron or what??! and I still tried to think maybe Cody would revenge on behalf of her late friend by dumping him out as soon as he is crazy a bout her. But no, it didn't happen at all. And then I know this saying, asshole meets asshole. So yeah. Even Meg's roommates know better than Cody how she really was depressed!! 

Another reason is Meg's parents who did not want to reach out her depression. Why did they protect Cody's feeling instead of their own daughter? What is wrong with this book??! It leads you always to disappointment as soon as you hit final page. Just utterly disappointing!!! I am too mad to even write this review and then see a lot of reviewers think this book is hella good. What is so special about Cody until Meg's parents don't even want to help Meg? And it disgusts me even more when finding out that this story is a real one. I was like what theefuuuck this sick Cody even exists in real life! 

Oh one thing. I don't know why this book also mentions about suicidal process, like showing the readers how Meg did it. It is just bad. This book may encourage someone with depression out there to commit suicide too. Disappointing! Too disappointing! 

It is like reading some Wattpad stories. Even some stories on it have a lot of interesting plot twists. I don't understand why people say it otherwise. When I was reading chapter 4, I could even guess Cody and Ben would end up together. And I don't like the first pov, Cody, ewh. She seemed careless and a little bit ignorant. And the hate-love relationship is too boring. It's just too predictable.

1 star out of 5.

I strongly don't recommend this book. I also don't put this book on my instagram account of Bookish Bookstore. As a good client who offers some good imported books, I need to at least read a lot of YA genre books 'cause they are so popular and some of them have been adapted to movie (Paper Towns in 2 months, yeay!) So, I never want to put this book on display. What a waste.

Popular posts from this blog

My Star by Robert Browning

Image
My Star by Robert Browning  Poem Analysis Today, I'd like to present my poem analysis; My Star by Robert Browning . This poem analysis would be divided into three parts, namely: introduction which will tell a brief background life of the poet, then to the content where there will be summary and intrinsic elements of this poem, and then move to the conclusion as the finish line. But more importantly, you need to know why I choose this poem, which belongs to Men and Women (1885)  poems collections of Browning. It is because this dainty love lyric is just beautiful and simple, in words-chosen and easy to understand too. More importantly, this poem shows us how the beauty of a person is different depending on its beholder. Yet, we should respect the differences. 
Read more

The Era of Puritanism (1564-1660): Literary Works

Image
The reign of the Puritans also produce a large amount of literature (poetry, prose), but drama could not thrive because it is prohibited by the authorities. Drama regarded as a nest of immorality by the Puritan authorities. It is just so different with Elizabeth period where drama produces a lot of outstanding works. So we can see that the literary works of Puritan period are just different from Elizabeth period. In period of Puritan literature, there are three groups of poems; metaphysical, cavalier and Puritan. Here are the complete version of the era of Puritanism (1564-1660): Literary Works. Poetry We can find poems in this period are way too different from the previous one. We may even call the literary in this period as the depression kind of expression. If in Elizabethan period we know some greatest poets like Edmund Spenser, Philip Sidney, George Chapman and Thomas Sackville who each of them expressing their emotions through their works. The emotions here are like t...
Read more

Gender Stereotypes and Performativity in Frozen Movie

Image
Since it is holiday already, so I have more time to gather the data and publish this article, which is entitled Gender Stereotypes and Performativity in Frozen movie . I analyzed this movie in order to complete the assignment given in Children literature class. But it turned out interesting! I focused only one theory; performativity from Judith Butler. Check out the analysis from my paper! The writer analyzes Frozen movie by focusing only one theory; performativity from Judith Butler. In order to not broaden it into some theories that may be found in the plot, the writer thinks the misconstrued-performances of the main characters, Anna and Elsa are easily seen and become vast majority start from the beginning until the very end of the movie. But it doesn’t mean other theories are forgotten. Something that the writer immediately thought about when finishing the movie was that Frozen is perhaps the queerest animated film ever produced by Disney–queer as being a theoretical practic...
Read more